Harvey Weinstein Retrial Erupts Into Chaos Amid Split Verdicts and Jury Turmoil

Screaming matches, mistrial requests, and a fractured jury mark the latest chapter in the disgraced producer’s high-stakes legal battle. The New York rape retrial of Harvey Weinstein has spiraled into chaotic courtroom drama, complete with shouting jurors, partial verdicts, and a desperate plea for a mistrial from the once-powerful Hollywood mogul. Now in its second week of deliberations, the jury’s dysfunction is raising serious questions about the integrity of the proceedings.

On Wednesday, the jury in Harvery Weinstein case informed Judge Curtis Farber that it had reached a split decision: guilty on one count of criminal sexual act in the first degree involving Miriam Haley, not guilty on the same charge related to Kaja Sokola, and no consensus yet on the pivotal allegations from Jessica Mann.

Each charge of first-degree criminal sexual act carries a maximum sentence of 25 years, meaning Weinstein’s fate remains hanging in the balance as the final verdict looms.

Chaos in the Jury Room

Behind the scenes, tensions among the 12 jurors—seven women and five men—have boiled over into screaming, threats, and refusals to cooperate. The jury foreman reportedly told Judge Farber, “I can’t go back in there with the other jurors,” prompting the judge to send the panel home early in hopes of cooling tempers.

According to reports, at least one juror threatened another with violence, and multiple complaints have been submitted to the court over abusive conduct inside the deliberation room.

Judge Curtis Farber confirmed the dysfunction but refused to grant a mistrial, despite an impassioned plea from Harvey Weinstein himself.

Harvey Weinstein Cries Foul

“This is my life that’s on the line,” the 73-year-old Harvey Weinstein told the judge on Wednesday. “I’m not getting a fair trial. This is not fair.” Still battling health issues and under constant media scrutiny, Weinstein appeared visibly distressed as his request for a mistrial was denied once again.

Harvey Weinstein’s 23-year prison sentence from his original 2020 New York conviction was overturned by an appeals court in 2024, leading to this retrial, which is now making headlines for all the wrong reasons.

The Stakes Remain High

Harvey Weinstein has long maintained that his encounters with accusers were consensual, while prosecutors argue he used his power and influence in Hollywood to lure, exploit, and assault aspiring actresses and models. His defense team has continued to paint the accusers as opportunists, claiming, “They’re all women with broken dreams.”

The latest developments suggest that Harvey Weinstein’s retrial—already a lightning rod for debates around power, celebrity, and justice—could end in more controversy than clarity.

With deliberations paused and jurors on edge, all eyes are on the courtroom as the final charge involving Jessica Mann still hangs undecided.